4.1
5
26 ratings
MLB 23 Review: 28 Ratings, Pros and Cons
Date: (Last saved review: ) - Review: CommentChoisir.fr
Check all the 28 reviews find on Video Games MLB 23, with the 26 ratings, comments, pros & cons from the reviewers.
Theses reviews and tests from Video Games magazines and websites give 26 ratings, we get this average rating to this MLB product : 4.1/5.
MLB 23 review : With an average rating of 4.1/5, you can buy MLB 23 with your eyes closed (or almost). The opinions of the testers seem unanimous !
MLB 23 ratings
26 Ratings ranked from best to worst, green to good grades, red to bad,
Average rating: 4.1/5.
Source: https://www.commentChoisir.fr
| 9/10 Nintendo World Report | 90/100 COGconnected | 9/10 M2 Gaming | 9/10 GeekCulture |
| 90/100 TheXboxHub | 4.4/5 GamesCreed | 8.75/10 GameInformer | 8.5/10 The Games Machine |
| 85/100 Gaming Trend | 85/100 MeuPlayStation | 8.36/10 Pizza Fria | 8.2/10 GamesVillage |
| 4/5 Twinfinite | 4/5 GodIsAGeek | 8/10 wccftech | 8/10 GamingBolt |
| 8/10 Shacknews | 8/10 Tom’s Hardware (it) | 8/10 Geeky | 8/10 Game-eXperience.it |
| 8/10 ILoveVG | 7.5/10 Lords of Gaming | 7.3/10 SpazioGames | 3.5/5 Hardcore Gamer |
| 7/10 Nintendo Life | 7/10 Push Square |
1 Preview or review without rating: Console Creatures
For Video Games, ratings are sometimes different depending on the platform. Please refer to the good review...
Pros and cons for MLB 23 List of reviews and ratings
To better compare, we looked for you the advantages and disadvantages of Below and the notes given by specialized sites.
9
10
Nintendo World Report
Excellent, flexible gameplay
Negro League Storylines history mode
Smart tweaks to Diamond Dynasty
Negro League Storylines history mode
Smart tweaks to Diamond Dynasty
Visuals work but look rough
reviewed at 28/03/2023 - [read the full review on Nintendo World Report]
90
100
COGconnected
Negro League storylines
Excellent audio upgrades
Gorgeous visuals
Best baseball simulation out there
Excellent audio upgrades
Gorgeous visuals
Best baseball simulation out there
Minor commentary issues
Music isn?t always utilized properly
Convoluted player management screens
Music isn?t always utilized properly
Convoluted player management screens
reviewed at 10/03/2023 - Test MLB The Show 23 ? Tech Test Lessons [read the full review on COGconnected]
[90/100] reviewed at 01/04/2023 - Test MLB The Show 23 ? History In The Making [read the full review on COGconnected]
[90/100] reviewed at 01/04/2023 - Test MLB The Show 23 ? History In The Making [read the full review on COGconnected]
9
10
M2 Gaming
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 11/04/2023 - [read the full review on M2 Gaming]
9
10
GeekCulture
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 14/04/2023 - [read the full review on GeekCulture]
90
100
TheXboxHub
It looks absolutely amazing
Home commands
Negro Leagues mode is superb
Dynamic difficulty is delicious
Home commands
Negro Leagues mode is superb
Dynamic difficulty is delicious
Very similar to MLB The Show 22
reviewed at 24/04/2023 - [read the full review on TheXboxHub]
4.4
5
GamesCreed
Storylines
The return of Team affinity
Button accuracy
Improved Franchise and March to October modes
More realistic movement and behaviours
Gorgeous visuals
Great music playlist
The return of Team affinity
Button accuracy
Improved Franchise and March to October modes
More realistic movement and behaviours
Gorgeous visuals
Great music playlist
A few bugs and glitches
reviewed at 09/04/2023 - [read the full review on GamesCreed]
8.75
10
GameInformer
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 12/04/2023 - [read the full review on GameInformer]
8.5
10
The Games Machine
Excellent game structure
Many game modes, old and new, well thought out
Great atmosphere
Many game modes, old and new, well thought out
Great atmosphere
Online not always impeccable
Player models feel the weight of the years
Player models feel the weight of the years
reviewed at 06/04/2023 - [read the full review on The Games Machine]
85
100
Gaming Trend
The Negro Leagues game mode is sheer brilliance
Stunning graphics look better than ever
The most responsive and consistent gameplay to date
Captain cards in Diamond Dynasty are fun additions
Stunning graphics look better than ever
The most responsive and consistent gameplay to date
Captain cards in Diamond Dynasty are fun additions
Road to the Show offered nothing new
Seasonal Diamond Dynasty causes longevity concerns
No RTTS, Stubbs, or Data import availability
Seasonal Diamond Dynasty causes longevity concerns
No RTTS, Stubbs, or Data import availability
reviewed at 07/04/2023 - [read the full review on Gaming Trend]
85
100
MeuPlayStation
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 21/04/2023 - [read the full review on MeuPlayStation]
8.36
10
Pizza Fria
The Story Mode with the Black Leagues is amazing
FaceScan technology allows you to customize your own reader
Variety of equipment and customization possibilities
Multiple ways to set up the game, with a cool tutorial
FaceScan technology allows you to customize your own reader
Variety of equipment and customization possibilities
Multiple ways to set up the game, with a cool tutorial
For beginners, the game can be too complex.
Some pieces seem repetitive
Some pieces seem repetitive
reviewed at 03/04/2023 - [read the full review on Pizza Fria]
8.2
10
GamesVillage
A challenging gaming experience
Improved graphics
Challenging and informative modes
Improved graphics
Challenging and informative modes
Maybe not suitable for amateurs
reviewed at 30/03/2023 - [read the full review on GamesVillage]
4
5
Twinfinite
Storylines is one of the best additions to this franchise.
More rewarding and engaging Scouting mechanics.
The most accessible Diamond Dynasty yet.
Endless Game Modes and Options.
More rewarding and engaging Scouting mechanics.
The most accessible Diamond Dynasty yet.
Endless Game Modes and Options.
Road to the Show overall is lacking and uninspired.
The flattest commentary of the sports simulations.
No Online Franchise mode.
The flattest commentary of the sports simulations.
No Online Franchise mode.
reviewed at 27/03/2023 - [read the full review on Twinfinite]
4
5
GodIsAGeek
Looks and sounds great
Intuitive baseball gameplay
Loads of modes
Intuitive baseball gameplay
Loads of modes
Visuals are poor in places
Load times are too long
Load times are too long
reviewed at 27/03/2023 - [read the full review on GodIsAGeek]
8
10
wccftech
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 28/03/2023 - [read the full review on wccftech]
8
10
GamingBolt
Storylines mode is a great way to learn about the game?s history and see it from a different perspective
Slight gameplay improvements
Not messing with an already great formula.
Slight gameplay improvements
Not messing with an already great formula.
No major additions to existing gameplay modes
Omission of pitch clock.
Omission of pitch clock.
reviewed at 31/03/2023 - [read the full review on GamingBolt]
8
10
Shacknews
Gameplay is still intuitive and satisfying
The Negro Leagues is a beautiful new addition
Diamond Dynasty is still an endless well of content and customization
Face scans for Road to the Show
The Negro Leagues is a beautiful new addition
Diamond Dynasty is still an endless well of content and customization
Face scans for Road to the Show
Latency in online matches
Menu design could use some work
Menu design could use some work
reviewed at 01/01/1970 - [read the full review on Shacknews]
8
10
Tom’s Hardware (it)
Exciting Storylines Mode
Creating teams in the most exciting diamond dynasty
Less static defense phase
Creating teams in the most exciting diamond dynasty
Less static defense phase
Visually, it stayed in previous chapters
Road to the Show is practically the same as last year
Road to the Show is practically the same as last year
reviewed at 01/04/2023 - [read the full review on Tom’s Hardware (it)]
8
10
Geeky
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 09/04/2023 - [read the full review on Geeky]
8
10
Game-eXperience.it
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 10/04/2023 - [read the full review on Game-eXperience.it]
8
10
ILoveVG
Graphics
Sound
Long time...
Sound
Long time...
... Even though I was repetitive
Difficulty
Difficulty
reviewed at 22/04/2023 - [read the full review on ILoveVG]
7.5
10
Lords of Gaming
Negro Leagues Stories an excellent new gameplay mode
Road to the Show trainings have more practical options
Wide variety of uniforms to get through packs from the Negro Leagues to the World Baseball Class
Road to the Show trainings have more practical options
Wide variety of uniforms to get through packs from the Negro Leagues to the World Baseball Class
UI can be hard to read at times
Announcer dialogue is literally the same, canned lines from years past
Notable bugs and glitches
Announcer dialogue is literally the same, canned lines from years past
Notable bugs and glitches
reviewed at 06/04/2023 - [read the full review on Lords of Gaming]
7.3
10
SpazioGames
Added Storylines mode
The revision of Diamond Dynasty
The revision of Diamond Dynasty
Missing news for other modes
Another title of the last generation
Another title of the last generation
reviewed at 17/04/2023 - [read the full review on SpazioGames]
3.5
5
Hardcore Gamer
No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.
reviewed at 27/03/2023 - [read the full review on Hardcore Gamer]
7
10
Nintendo Life
Full-featured port with all modes from other versions
New Storylines mode makes a more well-rounded package
Looks decent for the most part
Still plays a good game on Switch
New Storylines mode makes a more well-rounded package
Looks decent for the most part
Still plays a good game on Switch
Frame rate issues in places and slightly sluggish controls
Franchise and Road to the Show modes need a revamp
Online play against other platforms going to be an uphill battle
Franchise and Road to the Show modes need a revamp
Online play against other platforms going to be an uphill battle
reviewed at 28/03/2023 - [read the full review on Nintendo Life]
7
10
Push Square
Negro Leagues story is sublime
Greater emphasis on fielding attributes
Batter/pitcher matchups improved
Tons of team building potential in Diamond Dynasty
Greater emphasis on fielding attributes
Batter/pitcher matchups improved
Tons of team building potential in Diamond Dynasty
Visuals look dated and drab
Road to the Show has stood still
There are microtransactions
Road to the Show has stood still
There are microtransactions
reviewed at 29/03/2023 - [read the full review on Push Square]
-
not scored
Console CreaturesStill the best audio and visual presentation in sports games
"Storylines" is a great example of how sports simulators are becoming great history lessons
"Storylines" is a great example of how sports simulators are becoming great history lessons
"Diamond Dynasty" and "Storylines" are the stars of this season. "Road To The Show" and "Franchise" could use some spring training.
reviewed at 28/03/2023 - [read the full review on Console Creatures]
MLB 23 Users & Customers reviews
(affiliate links)
Reviews of others Video Games MLB
Test MLB 25, Test MLB 24, Test MLB 22,... and find all reviews find for brand MLB
Info and ConclusionMLB 23
What rating did MLB 23 get?
An average rating of 4.1/5 with 26 ratings.What price ?
Your review and rating for MLB 23:
Did you buy or tested this product ?
