Sherlock Holmes Chapter One Review: 35 Ratings, Pros and Cons

3.7

27 ratings

Sherlock Holmes Chapter One Review: 35 Ratings, Pros and Cons

Date: 02/06/2021 (Last saved review: 27/04/2022) - Review: CommentChoisir.fr

Check all the 35 reviews find on Video Games Sherlock Holmes Chapter One, with the 27 ratings, comments, pros & cons from the reviewers.
Theses reviews and tests from Video Games magazines and websites give 27 ratings, we get this average rating to this Sherlock Holmes product : 3.7/5.

All Reviews

» Video Games Reviews

» Sherlock Holmes Chapter One Reviews

Sherlock Holmes Chapter One review : Sherlock Holmes Chapter One seems to be very good in the category of Video Games, the reviews are very positive overall for this product and the "Pros" are higher than "Cons".
NDA on Reviews ? Please note that 18 reviews were published the same day 15/11/2021.

Warning this product has been rated 1 times severely, with very low scores, read the tests associated with these ratings.

1/ Sherlock Holmes Chapter One ratings
2/ Pros and cons Sherlock Holmes Chapter One
3/ Videos-test Sherlock Holmes Chapter One

Sherlock Holmes Chapter One ratings

27 Ratings ranked from best to worst, green to good grades, red to bad, Average rating: 3.7/5.
Source: https://www.commentChoisir.fr

9.2/10 VideoChums	9/10 JVFrance	8.6/10 Xbox Tavern	8.5/10 wccftech
85/100 Gaming Trend	8.5/10 TechRaptor	8/10 GameSpew	8/10 GameReactor
8/10 Shacknews	4/5 PXLBBQ	8/10 GameLove	8/10 Cultured Vultures
78/100 COGconnected	7.7/10 AusGamers	3.8/5 Movies Games and Tech	15/20 JVL
7.5/10 ActuGaming	7.4/10 tuttoteK	7/10 Well Played	3.5/5 GamesRadar
7/10 GameSpot	3.5/5 GamesCreed	6.5/10 GamersGlobal	6/10 Push Square
6/10 GamingBolt	6/10 GameKult.com	2/5 Twinfinite

5 Preview or review without rating: Chalgyr's Game Room, JeuxVideo.com, XboxSquad, Xboxygen, New Game Plus

For Video Games, ratings are sometimes different depending on the platform. Please refer to the good review...

Pros and cons for Sherlock Holmes Chapter One List of reviews and ratings

To better compare, we looked for you the advantages and disadvantages of Below and the notes given by specialized sites.

9.2

VideoChums

Notification system does an excellent job of providing clues and information
Stunning visuals / sprawling open-world map
Numerous detailed and enjoyable side-stories

Occasional issues with progression
Map could use a HUD option

reviewed at 15/11/2021 - [read the full review on VideoChums]

JVFrance

No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.

reviewed at 02/06/2021 - PREVIEW | On a testé Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One sur PC [read the full review on JVFrance]
[9/10] reviewed at 15/11/2021 - TEST | Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One ? Des lettres de noblesse au genre et à l'univers de Conan Doyle [read the full review on JVFrance]

8.6

Xbox Tavern

Side Cases are plentiful and just as interesting as the main plot
No handholding ensures you get immersed in the adventure
Sherlock?s personality evolution shines
Constantly unexpected plot twists
Combat can be turned off completely

Combat is dull and forgettable

reviewed at 02/12/2021 - [read the full review on Xbox Tavern]

8.5

wccftech

Engaging story
Charming characters
Huge variety of cases
Masterfully crafted investigation mechanics
Fitting open-world mechanics

Collectibles and Bandit Lairs feel a little too "gamey"
Combat is not particularly deep

reviewed at 15/11/2021 - [read the full review on wccftech]

100

Gaming Trend

Deep, fascinating story
Sherlock as a young adult
The open world of Cordona
Replayability

Getting stuck
Framerate stutters

reviewed at 15/11/2021 - [read the full review on Gaming Trend]

8.5

TechRaptor

Excellent Deductive Gameplay
Plenty Of Player Freedom
Compelling Central Mystery
Great Side Content
Surprisingly Powerful Story

Empty Open World
Weak Combat
Technical Issues

reviewed at 05/11/2021 - [read the full review on TechRaptor]

GameSpew

No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.

reviewed at 15/11/2021 - [read the full review on GameSpew]

GameReactor

An incredible open world. Interesting new mechanics. Well written and thought-provoking story. Solid graphics and presentation. Plenty of content.

Main story ends too abruptly. Investigative mechanics lacks a bit of depth.

reviewed at 15/11/2021 - [read the full review on GameReactor]

Shacknews

Solid investigative mechanics throughout
Enjoyable mysteries well worth solving
The island of Cordona is fun to explore
A lot of side activity to explore alongside the main mystery
A very good soundtrack blending classic and Mediterranean style

Animations are sometime glitchy and stiff
Combat is boring and feels forced in
Mystery solutions can sometimes feel esoteric

reviewed at 15/11/2021 - [read the full review on Shacknews]

PXLBBQ

No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.

reviewed at 19/11/2021 - [read the full review on PXLBBQ]

GameLove

No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.

reviewed at 09/12/2021 - [read the full review on GameLove]

Cultured Vultures

No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.

reviewed at 15/11/2021 - [read the full review on Cultured Vultures]

100

COGconnected

Beautiful open world setting
Interesting mysteries to solve
Smartly written

Mechanics can be convoluted
Poor combat
Pacing is sometimes slow
Character animations are pretty basic
Inconsistent voice acting

[78/100] reviewed at 15/11/2021 - Test Sherlock Holmes Chapter One ? The Most Ambitious Mystery Yet [read the full review on COGconnected]
reviewed at 17/11/2021 - Test Sherlock Holmes Chapter One Video ? A Mystery Worth Exploring [read the full review on COGconnected]

7.7

AusGamers

An incredibly well-written story
Unbelievable voice-acting and delivery of characters
Excellent, broad set of tools to exploit in a deep investigation system
Genuinely engaging when everything gels

Borked an clunky when things don't gel, which happens too often
Just not a great delivery of coherent tech
Game-world art and art direction is awash with white and not enough character
Animations aren't great and add to the game's "clunky" feel

reviewed at 24/11/2021 - [read the full review on AusGamers]

3.8

Movies Games and Tech

A lush environment
Accurate imagery.
Fun and lively audio.
Excellent acting.
Simple controls.
Plenty of replay value.

There is a sense of Déjà Vu with the character models and environments.
The open-world wasn't as expansive as I'd hoped for.

reviewed at 14/02/2022 - [read the full review on Movies Games and Tech]

JVL

No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.

reviewed at 01/01/1970 - [read the full review on JVL]

7.5

ActuGaming

No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.

reviewed at 27/04/2022 - [read the full review on ActuGaming]

7.4

tuttoteK

No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.

reviewed at 15/11/2021 - [read the full review on tuttoteK]

Well Played

The relationship between Sherlock and Jon is excellently written and acted
Fresh and emotional narrative
Solid detective gameplay
Cordona often looks beautiful
Speaking of beautiful, young Sherlock
Combat can be turned off

Combat is terrible
Open world feels a little soulless
Some performance issues
Too many people buying rugs

reviewed at 15/11/2021 - [read the full review on Well Played]

3.5

GamesRadar

Does detective puzzling like no other series
Hot Holmes

Problematic like your old uncle at Thanksgiving
Budget battles

reviewed at 15/11/2021 - [read the full review on GamesRadar]

GameSpot

No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.

reviewed at 19/11/2021 - [read the full review on GameSpot]

3.5

GamesCreed

No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.

reviewed at 28/11/2021 - [read the full review on GamesCreed]

6.5

GamersGlobal

No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.

reviewed at 17/11/2021 - [read the full review on GamersGlobal]

Push Square

Returning Sherlock Holmes mechanics are still really solid
Good disguise system
Combat is just good enough

Frustrating new detective elements
Eavesdropping feels like trial and error
Dull open world
Awful frame rate, many technical problems

reviewed at 15/11/2021 - [read the full review on Push Square]

GamingBolt

Spot on performances, an interesting take on the titular characters, lots of stuff to do in side-activities

Lack of facial animations and lip-syncing, Fun but thin combat loop, padded out story, inconsequential choice system

reviewed at 15/11/2021 - [read the full review on GamingBolt]

GameKult.com

No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.

reviewed at 01/12/2021 - [read the full review on GameKult.com]

Twinfinite

Big investigations are still pretty fun.
Carries over elements that worked from previous series.

Needless open-world and combat elements.
Quests pad runtime and take away from big investigations.
Vague “no hand-holding” gameplay prompts and direction.
Cordona is a bland and lifeless setting.

reviewed at 15/11/2021 - [read the full review on Twinfinite]

not scored

Chalgyr's Game Room

No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.

reviewed at 23/09/2021 - Sherlock Holmes Chapter One ? PC Preview [read the full review on Chalgyr's Game Room]
reviewed at 30/11/2021 - Test Sherlock Holmes Chapter One ? PC [read the full review on Chalgyr's Game Room]

not scored

JeuxVideo.com

No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.

reviewed at 15/11/2021 - [read the full review on JeuxVideo.com]

not scored

XboxSquad

No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.

reviewed at 15/11/2021 - [read the full review on XboxSquad]

not scored

Xboxygen

No "Pros & Cons" find for this reviewer.

reviewed at 15/11/2021 - [read the full review on Xboxygen]